|
Tuesday, August 26, 2008 - Vol. 10, No. 203
Today's comment is by Bob Bauman JD, former U.S. Congressman and now Senior Writer and Legal Counsel for The Sovereign Society.
Election year 2008 is officially the 18th U.S. presidential election during my lifetime. God willing, it will also be the 13th (maybe an unlucky number?) election that I've cast my vote for president.
Of course, I've also been a candidate elected to public office, so I know from experience that this is the time when all sorts of weird stories about candidates crawl out of the woodwork every election year.
A few months back there was a minor outcry claiming that Republican presidential candidate, Senator John McCain may not have been eligible to serve as president. The critics claimed he was not "a natural born citizen" as required by the U.S. Constitution.
Senator McCain was born in the U.S. Panama Canal Zone in 1936, where his father was stationed in the U.S. Navy. This outcry was more or less silenced when the U.S. Senate passed a bi-partisan resolution endorsing their colleagues' "natural born" status.
Yet Another Unnatural Born Candidate?
Now comes one Philip J. Berg. He is a former member of Pennsylvania's Democratic State Committee and former deputy attorney general of Pennsylvania. Berg also happens to be a highly disgruntled Hillary Clinton fan, who was backing her for president.
Berg filed a lawsuit last week in U.S District Court. He is asking the court to declare Obama ineligible for the presidency because he is not a natural born American citizen. He has asked the court to prevent him from running for the position.
The Berg lawsuit claims that Obama's eligibility is doubtful on several grounds, including some Obama family members' allegations that he was born in Kenya. Berg is also questioning Obama's parents' citizenship status which he claims prevented them from automatically granting Obama U.S. citizenship. He also questions the authenticity of Obama's Hawaii birth certificate.
Berg has also claimed Obama was a citizen of Indonesia as a child and Obama retained that foreign citizenship into adulthood without recording an oath of allegiance to the United States. That's a requirement to retain your American citizenship.
As both an attorney and long-time citizenship expert, I know something about the legal tangle that can befall an innocent infant born to American parents in foreign lands.
Yes, sometimes the odd circumstances of a foreign birth can call into question a hapless child's American citizenship. However, I'll let the federal court decide whether Barack Obama fits into this category or not.
This Is Just a Smaller Symptom of a Greater Issue
Whether legitimate or not, this lawsuit raises a greater issue that impacts all Americans who have an official U.S. passport (which about 30% of us do).
In recent times, the U.S. government is using your U.S. passport as a means of coercion in various ways.
In the United States, the government will deny you a U.S. passport simply for being in debt to the Internal Revenue Service. You can also be denied a passport if you owe more than US$2,500 in back payments for court ordered child support.
Since 1986, the U.S. State Department has told the IRS about any American who renews their U.S. passports from a foreign address (certainly not a crime in any way). Passport renewals require an applicant's Social Security number, so the IRS uses this information to see if applicants have filed income tax returns.
An IRS official speaking in Zurich said the IRS is making a special effort to track down all U.S. citizens who renewed U.S. passports while living in Switzerland (you can surely guess why).
Your Passport Has Become a Tagging Device
More recently, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) used their all-powerful "fighting terrorism" excuse to track the movements of every U.S. passport that comes or goes by air or sea. They even added land border crossings to the list, so they essentially have a travel profile of each and every American.
As my colleague Mark Nestmann pointed out,
"Instead of known or suspected terrorists, the government is tracking everyone who crosses a U.S. border. And since there are no limits to how the government uses the data collected, the information is almost certain to be used for politically motivated surveillance."
I agree with Mark. The potential for abuse in this system is obvious.
"Imagine that such a system existed now, and the DHS were to release data 'in the public interest' that a leading presidential candidate had made previously undisclosed visits to Iran, North Korea, or Cuba."
The Berg lawsuit alleges Obama used his alleged "Indonesian passport" to visit Pakistan when he was 20 years old. Obama is lucky the DHS surveillance system didn't exist back then, or that trip could have damaged Citizen Obama quest for the White House.
Avoid the U.S. Government-Issued Digital Stalkers
Even if this surveillance system is up and running, you can still avoid these digital stalkers when you travel. You can simply opt to travel with another passport when you travel between countries outside of the United States.
If you're a U.S. citizen, you must use your U.S. passport when you enter or leave the United States. But you're under no such obligation when you enter or leave other countries.
I have no way of knowing the merits of the Berg lawsuit, but the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that American citizens retain their citizenship when there is no clear intent to end that status.
The Court has also supported American citizens' right to hold dual citizenship. Those rulings would seem to protect Senator Obama's American status, although he might qualify as a "dual national."
What Is Dual Nationality and Why Does it Matter?
Dual nationality simply means that you are legally a citizen of two countries at the same time, qualified as such under each nation's law.
You could automatically receive this status if you're born in a foreign country and one of your parents is a U.S. citizen. In that case, you would become both a U.S. citizen and a citizen of the country where you're born.
Or you could become a dual national from an operation of law. For example, as a U.S. citizen, you could marry a foreigner and become a citizen of your spouse's nation. Or if you were a foreigner who was naturalized as a U.S. citizen, you can still retain your citizenship from the country of your birth.
You get the idea. The point is acquiring and using a foreign passport does not endanger your U.S. citizenship in any way. In fact, it's pretty common to retain two passports depending on your circumstances.
Some countries won't permit their citizens to hold a passport from another nation. This was the case in the U.S. until 1967, when the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the right of U.S. citizens to hold a second, foreign passport. Before that time, the official rule was that a person acquiring second nationality automatically lost U.S. citizenship.
Since 1967, the government generally presumes a U.S. citizen does not intend to surrender citizenship. You have to produce proof of that intention before the U.S. government will officially let you give up your U.S. citizenship (i.e. "expatriate"). The burden of proof then falls to the government to prove U.S. citizenship. This presumption is set forth in a U.S. Department of State publication, Advice About Possible Loss of U.S. Citizenship and Dual Nationality, (1990).
As a matter of policy, the U.S. Government recognizes dual nationality, but does not necessarily encourage it. (Once again, you can guess why - they would rather be able to track your every move.)
Just Say "NO" To the Stalking Big Brother
Big Brother Homeland Security is now mindlessly tracking our every move, so I think it wise for Americans to acquire a second passport. You need a second passport to guard against the inevitable restrictions that take away your freedom to travel and associate with foreigners.
I often hear concerns expressed about currency controls. But a far greater and very real threat is people control.
Now you can begin to see why a second passport may be highly useful. Your qualification for a second nation's passport, one that comes without restrictive strings attached, can serve as your additional passport to greater freedom.
That official document can be your key to a whole new world of free movement, expanded international investment, greater flexibility, and adventure. In addition, it can mean safe passage without delay.
BOB BAUMAN, Legal Counsel
EDITOR'S NOTE: Bob is the author of the long-time Sovereign Society best-seller, The Passport Book (now in a 6th edition). This all-inclusive guide gives you facts, figures and helpful how-tos about living in dozens of countries abroad. You can pick up your own copy here.
|