Clouds Cover Land of the Rising Sun - Again
Today's comment is by Eric Roseman, our Investment Director and editor of Commodity Trend Alert.
Dear A-Letter Reader,
Nobody said contrarian value investing was easy. And when it comes to Japan, that task continues to be a painful exercise in patience as capital markets continue to decline amid a mish-mash of political uncertainty, a strong yen and stalled economic growth since April.
The third quarter has been a bad period for global stocks as investors grapple with a crash in sub-prime mortgage-backed securities, a funding crisis in global short-term money-markets and several hedge fund and bank failures in Europe and the United States. The MSCI World Index of industrialized stock markets has declined 2.2% since June 30.
But in Japan, the global sell-off has morphed into an extended bear market. Stock-market values continue to get cheaper following the resignation last week of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. Handcuffed by a minority government and a host of ministerial resignations all summer, Mr. Abe's departure added fuel to a bear-market fire in Japanese stocks.
Surprising global investors, Japanese second quarter gross domestic product actually contracted 1.2% in the April to June period. It was the first quarterly contraction in four years following a string of bullish economic data for more than 48 months.
Investors Shy Away from Japanese Stocks
Making matters worse, a sharply stronger yen currency since late July has punctured the export sector where Japanese multinationals have relied on a cheap currency to gain international market share.
Japanese stocks, despite offering some of the best values based on a price-to-book-value ratio and price-to-cash-flow basis are still trying to find a bottom. The Nikkei Index of large-cap stocks has declined 6.4% in dollars this year. Meanwhile the even more distressed and cheaper 2nd Section Index of smaller companies has shed more than 10%.
It seems despite generally good corporate results for the entire market this year, investors just don't want anything to do with Japanese equities.
Will the Carry-Trade Come Back to Life?
What Japan needs now is a leader capable of carrying out the economic reforms implemented by former Prime Minister, Junichiro Koizumi. The main contender to fill Abe's shoes, Yasuo Fukuda, has vowed to follow in Koizumi's footsteps.
Fukuda doesn't offer bold economic policies and doesn't even enjoy wide popular support. But he does have all the right connections in the upper and lower Japanese houses. That's a pivotal advantage if economic reforms are to be continued and even accelerated under the LDP or Liberal Democratic Party. Indeed, international investors - responsible for more than 50% of daily trading volume in Japanese shares, would probably lift the depressed Nikkei and 2nd Section from the near-abyss on any positive political developments.
Other Uncertainties
Other factors contributing to market uncertainty is the Bank of Japan and the yen. The yen has rallied 8% from its lowest point in July versus the U.S. dollar as the infamous carry-trade has lost its momentum since markets peaked on July 19.
The Bank of Japan has threatened to continue raising short-term interest rates following its first hike last spring to a still historically low 0.50%. But throughout the summer, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) threatened to continue tightening monetary policy. The BOJ was hoping to raise interest rates to "normal" levels after years of ultra-loose monetary policy designed to resuscitate the deflationary-plagued economy from 1991 to 2003.
But with global money markets under the gun since July, the Bank of Japan is unlikely to resume rate hikes and that implies a gradual return to the carry-trade following the restoration of market stability, which has already begun since the Federal Reserve cut its discount rate on August 17 and the Fed Funds rate on September 18.
The carry-trade has been instrumental in fueling global liquidity and investors and traders alike have borrowed cheap yen at low interest rates and reinvested those proceeds into higher-yielding assets. The odds of the carry-trade returning, even grudgingly, will boost world markets and reduce the yen's value versus most global currencies. And that event alone should be enough to propel Japanese stocks higher.
Don't Dump Japanese Stocks Now
At this stage, I would continue to hold Japanese stocks and refrain from selling cheap securities. Cheap is getting cheaper in Japan. But at some point, investors will be rewarded and rather quickly.
Compared to the rest of the world, Japanese smaller companies trade at 65% - 80% discounts based on relative price-to-book-value ratios. The current price-to-book-value ratio of the Tokyo 2nd Section Index is 0.90 or a 10% discount to book-value.
And unlike larger Japanese companies, they don't rely on a cheap yen to boost exports, which makes this ongoing bear-market in values even more difficult to comprehend considering earnings have been mostly robust since 2003.
Japanese Small-Caps: Still Selling at a Value

In a market where just about everything has gone from bad to worse this year for investors, Japanese equities remain excellent values and should not be sold at these distressed levels.
A new Prime Minister, which will boost market sentiment by reinforcing economic reforms started under Koizumi, will probably act as the catalyst to finally drive equity prices higher. Stay invested in Japan.
ERIC ROSEMAN, Investment Director
|