Why Oil Shares ARE NOT Following Record Highs in Crude Oil…
Today's comment is by Eric Roseman, Investment Director and editor of Commodity Trend Alert.
Dear A-Letter Reader,
There’s yet another market anomaly happening this year. This one is hurting many commodity bulls who called the market right, but chose the wrong way to play the trend.
Despite another great year for crude oil, (recently trading north of US$109 per barrel), oil stocks are still in negative territory. This proves that under severe market circumstances like these, you can find disconnects between commodities and their corresponding stock plays. In other words, to capitalize on US$100 oil, you have to do more than just buy Exxon.
Rising Oil, Falling Energy Stocks?
It’s not the first time commodities have broken away from their respective natural resource stocks.
Back in 2002, crude oil went through the roof after forming a bottom in late 2001. But investors lost big money betting on energy stocks that same year.
In 2002, crude oil prices gained a whopping 52% while global stock markets suffered their third year of a grueling bear market. However, the largest oil stocks in the United States, as measured by the Energy Select Spiders ETF, plunged 15% in 2002.
Exxon Has Been a Dog This Year, While Crude Oil is Dandy

Exxon-Mobil, the world’s largest energy company based on market-capitalization fell 5.6% in 2002, including dividends. Chevron, declined 13.6% and Conoco-Phillips lost 12%. None of these companies posted a gain in a year when oil prices enjoyed their strongest advance in years.
In 2008, crude oil has once again deviated from the performance generated by oil stocks in the United States and abroad.
As of earlier this week, West Texas intermediate crude oil had gained nearly 13% in 2008. (Crude oil leapt to US$111/barrel as of yesterday.) Yet once again, a basket of the world’s largest oil companies has posted double-digit losses this year. Exxon-Mobil has shed 12%, Chevron has declined 9% and the Energy Spiders ETF is down 6% in 2008. They’re all failing to provide absolute returns in another bull market year for oil.
It’s not just U.S. oil companies. Foreign oil majors like Royal Dutch Shell has tanked 14% and Italy’s ENI is off 3%. Both stocks are denominated in stronger foreign currencies and have still logged declines in dollar terms.
Bear Markets Pull Most Stocks Lower
So what’s causing this strange anomaly between oil prices and oil stocks? For starters, it has more to do with the broader market’s performance than earnings or company specific events.
The velocity and severity of a bear market takes the majority of stocks and sectors to the basement. That’s what happened in 2002 and it’s happening again this year. The disconnect has arrived once more as surging oil prices has not helped stocks like Exxon-Mobil and Chevron.
In a bear market, and we’re in one right now, stock selling becomes so widespread that institutions and investors alike dump the good, the bad and the ugly. It’s extremely rare for a stock to rally during a bear market, despite harboring positive fundamentals or record earnings. That’s because the selling pressure is simply too enormous.
Turn to Commodity ETFs in a Bear Market for Stocks
If current trends continue, 2008 might look a lot like 2002 for oil investors. That year, crude oil soared 52% while the S&P 500 Index tanked 22%. That was its worst calendar year return since 1974. Oil stocks on both sides of the Atlantic posted losses.
In a bear market for common stocks, I would advise you to shift some of your commodity capital away from natural resource stocks and into commodity-backed exchange traded funds (ETFs) instead. Specifically, look for ETFs that invest directly in things like oil, natural gas, coffee, and wheat.
That’s where the big money will be made this year as most commodities futures continue to rally and stocks decline – even in the natural resource sector.
Oil prices might not rally far beyond this week’s highs in the midst of a slowdown in overseas economic growth and a U.S. recession. But if prices do continue to surge, the best way to play crude oil at this stage is to purchase an oil ETF, and not an oil stock.
A great investment idea is a terrible thing to waste. Look to commodity ETFs as a safer and ultimately, a more profitable way to invest in this historical bull market for raw materials.
ERIC ROSEMAN, Investment Director
P.S. My colleague, Mike Burnick has an entire service that tracks global ETFs all around the world in his service, Global Market Investor. Mike is playing this commodity rally, with three different bear-market-savvy ETFs that are capitalizing on the recent spikes in crude oil. Click Here to try out his service, for some safe alternatives to this year’s bear market for stocks.
|